Home | About | Donate

The Two Narratives of Palestine: The People Are United, the Factions Are Not

The Two Narratives of Palestine: The People Are United, the Factions Are Not

Ramzy Baroud

The International Conference on Palestine held in Istanbul between April 27-29 brought together many speakers and hundreds of academics, journalists, activists and students from Turkey and all over the world.

The Conference was a rare opportunity aimed at articulating a discourse of international solidarity that is both inclusive and forward thinking.

As so often happens, party leadership loses sight of why the party exists. Thus, instead of working for the good of the people, the party works to magnify its own importance. Look at the USA for a prime example.

The “Palestine Papers” has put to an end this Zionist myth that it is the “lack of a Palestinian peace partner” (rather than Israeli intransigence) that is the real obstacle to peace.

This week, the first of hundreds of leaked confidential Palestinian documents confirmed the suspicions of a growing number of observers that the rejectionists in the peace process are to be found on the Israeli, not Palestinian, side.


The bottom line is … the Palestinian Authority accepted Israel’s position on every key point: borders, Jerusalem, settlements, refugees.

On no major issue did the PA hold the line. None. The Palestinians offered Israel everything and Israel still said ‘no’ with the backing of the United States…

We pretend that the Palestinians still need to make concessions for peace when there are none left to make.

Identifying where the REAL obstacle to peace lies is the first best step towards achieving a just and lasting peace.

1 Like

The alleged lack of Palestinian non-violence is also a popular but demonstrably false Zionist construct. Aside from the obvious current non-violent efforts such as the Boycott Divestment Sanctions (BDS) movement, the history of non-violence in the Palestinian struggle has a long history.

When will there be a Palestinian Gandhi?

The reality of course is that Palestinian nonviolent resisters are not only active today but have a long and storied history in the Palestinian struggle. The real question is: why haven’t we heard about them?

Like many resisting oppression, Palestinian Gandhis are likely to be found in prisons after being repressed by Israeli soldiers or police or in the hospital after being brutally beaten or worse…

While some have adopted an Israeli narrative that identifies nonviolent Palestinian dissent [as something new, the reality is that Palestinians have consistently chosen nonviolent resistance before arms – from the general strikes of 1936, to the consistent appeals to international legal bodies, to the weekly demonstrations against the wall. It has been the continued dispossession at the hands of Israel, and the silence of the international community despite these nonviolent efforts, that has led some Palestinians to view violence as the only option.

The international community has an obligation to Palestinian nonviolent activists. Leaders cannot simply call on Palestinians to abandon violence in the face of Israeli occupation and remain silent when the nonviolent activists are politically repressed. This only reinforces the idea that the use of force reigns supreme and that Palestinians have no choice but to accept hardships at the hands of their Israeli lords.

We cannot lecture the dispossessed about non-violent alternatives and in return propose to do nothing (i.e. regular and systematic Israeli killing, beating and arresting of non-violent Palestinian leaders and protestors without consequences), or worse, to undermine them when they engage in such alternatives (i.e. BDS).

1 Like